By Martin Rawson
Published in Rundbrief, the journal of the Pedagogical Section in Dornach. Volume 22, Easter 2005
Download the full article and charts : The Role of Evaluation and Examination within Waldorf Education
This working paper deals with the question of examinations but first it is necessary to place the subject in the wider context of pedagogical examination.
What is evaluation?
Evaluation means knowing, establishing, making visible, comparing and assessing the value of something. These are quite different activities. Knowing means seeking the essential quality of something in its context. Establishing the value of something requires an analysis that identifies the relevant aspects since not all aspects are equally important even when we try to look at it in a holistic way. We set priorities in the form of value-systems. Assessing implies weighing the value of something, comparing it with other similar objects and at the same time valuing it -that is appreciating its unique qualities. In order to know the essence of something we must approach it with well-intentioned, loving interest. Well meaning interest is the starting point of any real evaluation.
Evaluation also has to do with testing. We are constantly being tested by life. In all social situations we are constantly being tested and questioned. In the past each culture had its own form of ritual testing. The essential phases of life were marked by various forms of trial. At puberty and later on reaching adult maturity young people were admitted into their society as full adults by way of ceremonies and initiations trials. Today we have mostly only bourgeois remainders of these rituals., They have been replaced by school exams. The need that young people have to be challenged and tested is not met through forms. Rather they seek their trials through all manner of risk-taking activities.
To read further download the article above
Keywords: evaluation in Waldorf schools, learning and testing, competence, class 2 study, child study, school reports, class reports, assessment, observation, portfolio,